Without Fear or Favor

Author: G. Alan Tarr
Publisher: Stanford University Press
ISBN: 9780804783507
Release Date: 2012-09-19
Genre: Law

The impartial administration of justice and the accountability of government officials are two of the most strongly held American values. Yet these values are often in direct conflict with one another. At the national level, the U.S. Constitution resolves this tension in favor of judicial independence, insulating judges from the undue influence of other political institutions, interest groups, and the general public. But at the state level, debate has continued as to the proper balance between judicial independence and judicial accountability. In this volume, constitutional scholar G. Alan Tarr focuses squarely on that debate. In part, the analysis is historical: how have the reigning conceptions of judicial independence and accountability emerged, and when and how did conflict over them develop? In part, the analysis is theoretical: what is the proper understanding of judicial independence and accountability? Tarr concludes the book by identifying the challenges to state-level judicial independence and accountability that have emerged in recent decades, assessing the solutions offered by the competing sides, and offering proposals for how to strike the appropriate balance between independence and accountability.

Independence Accountability and the Judiciary

Author: Guy Canivet
Publisher: British Inst of International & Comparative
ISBN: 0903067641
Release Date: 2006
Genre: Law

This new book explores the important and topical subject of judicial independence and judicial accountability. Contributions from distinguished practitioners and academics place these twin issues within a comparative law perspective, showing how legal systems across the world have adapted to recent developments in this field.

A Place Apart

Author: Martin L. Friedland
Publisher: Canadian Government Publishing
ISBN: UIUC:30112021681413
Release Date: 1995
Genre: Judges

How accountable are judges for their decisions? Should they have greater independence? This study, by University of Toronto law professor Martin Friedland, examines the judiciary in Canada from a variety of perspectives and provides recommendations on these issues to the Canadian Judicial Council. Persons consulted include not only judges but also lawyers, government officials, administrators, and others. Topics include judicial selection, discipline, the administration of the courts, and more.

Judges on Trial

Author: Shimon Shetreet
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
ISBN: 9781107013674
Release Date: 2013-10-24
Genre: Law

This study of the English judiciary stimulates a discussion of the factors shaping judicial independence, including accountability and constitutional adjudication.

Regulating Judges

Author: Richard Devlin
Publisher: Edward Elgar Publishing
ISBN: 9781786430793
Release Date: 2016-12-30
Genre: Law

Regulating Judges presents a novel approach to judicial studies. It goes beyond the traditional clash of judicial independence versus judicial accountability. Drawing on regulatory theory, Richard Devlin and Adam Dodek argue that judicial regulation is multi-faceted and requires us to consider the complex interplay of values, institutional norms, procedures, resources and outcomes. Inspired by this conceptual framework, the book invites scholars from 19 jurisdictions to describe and critique the regulatory regimes for a variety of countries from around the world.

The Politics of Judicial Independence in the UK s Changing Constitution

Author: Graham Gee
Publisher: Cambridge University Press
ISBN: 9781316240533
Release Date: 2015-03-12
Genre: Law

Judicial independence is generally understood as requiring that judges must be insulated from political life. The central claim of this work is that far from standing apart from the political realm, judicial independence is a product of it. It is defined and protected through interactions between judges and politicians. In short, judicial independence is a political achievement. This is the main conclusion of a three-year research project on the major changes introduced by the Constitutional Reform Act 2005, and the consequences for judicial independence and accountability. The authors interviewed over 150 judges, politicians, civil servants and practitioners to understand the day-to-day processes of negotiation and interaction between politicians and judges. They conclude that the greatest threat to judicial independence in future may lie not from politicians actively seeking to undermine the courts, but rather from their increasing disengagement from the justice system and the judiciary.

Accountability in the Contemporary Constitution

Author: Nicholas Bamforth
Publisher: OUP Oxford
ISBN: 9780191648953
Release Date: 2013-11-14
Genre: Law

Accountability is regarded as a central feature of modern constitutionalism. At a general level, this prominence is perhaps unsurprising, given the long history of the idea. However, in many constitutional democracies, including the UK and the USA, it has acquired a particular resonance in contemporary circumstances with the declining power of social deference, the expanding reach of populist accountability mechanisms, and the increasing willingness of citizens to find mechanisms for challenging official decision-making. These essays, by public law scholars, seek to explore how ideas of and mechanisms associated with accountability play a part in the contemporary constitution. While the majority of contributors concentrate on the United Kingdom, others provide comparative discussion with particular reference to the United States and aspects of European Union law. The main focus of the volume is the contemporary UK constitution. Chapters are included which analyse the historical context (including the role of Dicey), common law constitutionalism, the constitutional role of Parliament, the constitutional role of the courts, judicial accountability, human rights protection under the constitution and the contribution of non-judicial accountability mechanisms. Further chapters explore the public service principle, the impact of new public management on public service delivery, and the relationship between accountability and regulation. Finally accountability is discussed in the light of constitutional reform including the challenges posed by the 'multi-layered' government at the supra national level of EU membership and sub-national national levels of devolution and local government.

Judicial Councils Independence and Accountability

Author: Steven Reed Minegar
ISBN: OCLC:696156254
Release Date: 2010

ABSTRACT:The debate over how to balance the concepts of judicial independence and accountability has become more controversial with the recent choice of many countries to adopt judicial councils for administrative and disciplinary purposes in the courts. Both of these concepts are considered vital to a well-functioning judiciary in a democratic context, but there is much disagreement over how best to balance them. Judicial councils are attempts to do so, but their installation has added many more questions to what are concepts already in need of stronger definition. Brazil's Conselho Nacional de Justiça (National Council of Justice, or NCJ) is a recent example of a debate over these two concepts and a country's attempt to balance them through a judicial council. The NCJ is a 15-member body composed of judges, lawyers, prosecutors, and civil servants selected by their respective courts and branches. It is endowed with administrative, budgetary, and disciplinary functions with jurisdiction over the national court system, that is: some federal courts, state courts, and specialized courts. The NCJ was a highly controversial proposal because it included members from outside the judiciary.

Judicial Accountabilities in New Europe

Author: Daniela Piana
Publisher: Routledge
ISBN: 9781317110101
Release Date: 2016-05-06
Genre: Law

This volume focuses on a highly challenging aspect of all European democracies, namely the issue of combining guarantees of judicial independence and mechanisms of judicial accountability. It does so by filling the gap in European scholarship between the two policy sectors of enlargement and judicial cooperation and by taking full stock of an interdisciplinary literature, spanning from comparative politics, socio-legal studies and European studies. Judicial Accountabilities in New Europe presents an insightful account of the judicial reforms adopted by new member States to embed the principle of the rule of law in their democratic institutions, along with the guidelines of quality of justice promoted by European institutions in all member States.

The Culture of Judicial Independence

Author: Shimon Shetreet
Publisher: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers
ISBN: 9789004215856
Release Date: 2011-11-11
Genre: Law

This volume analyzes the development of a culture of Judicial Independence in comparative perspectives, to offer an examination of the conceptual foundations of the principle of judicial independence and to discuss in detail the practical challenges facing judiciaries in different jurisdictions.